Smoker Turning Food Black (What’s Going On)

For most backyard cooks, smoking food is usually a pleasurable activity.

However, you may have recently noticed that your smoked meats and vegetables are turning an unusual shade of black—a potentially dangerous situation for someone who is new to this type of cooking! 

One possible culprit is a lack of ventilation, which can leave a black layer on food.

Lack of care for the smoker’s own physical well-being is another possible contributor.

Sometimes oil from the food can drip onto the smoker’s burner, where it will burn, creating more smoke than usual and leaving a black residue on the food.

This blog post takes an in-depth look at What’s causing the issue and how to avoid it in order to consistently produce excellent, properly cooked meals.

We’ll touch on topics such as temperature control, proper preparation, and more so you feel equipped to handle this issue immediately.

Let’s get started – why not give yourself some smoky satisfaction without any worries?

What causes my meat to turn black in the smoker?

meat to turn black in the smoker

The possible problems that can cause your meat to turn black are the following:

  1. The Creosote Problem (The main One)
  2. Not enough oxygen 
  3. Too much smoke 
  4. The type of wood 
  5. The temperature 
  6. The length of time 
  7. The moisture content 
  8. The fat content 
  9. Time

1- The Creosote Problem (The Main One)

What Is Creosote? 

High temperatures in your smoker leave behind a thick, oily residue known as creosote.

This unattractive critter often develops on meat and other foods within your smoker, altering their appearance and flavor in the process.

The chemical not only alters the appearance and texture of your food but also alters the flavor.

Creosote has a bitter aftertaste and can leave a tingly or numb feeling in the mouth and on the tongue.

A small amount of this chemical is all it takes to turn a high-end beef tenderloin into something the dog will eat.

It can turn your cherished smoker into something you’re ready to throw away and is guaranteed to ruin your favorite meal.

On the other hand, there is a silver lining to this difficulty.

What Causes The Creosote Buildup?

  • There is an excessive amount of fuel contained within the smoker.
  • Your coals are becoming too hot too quickly.
  • You are not exercising sufficient command over the temperature.
  • The interior of the unit does not have a sufficient amount of airflow.
  • The coals are smoldering, but they are not yet sufficiently hot. :

How To Test For Creosote?

To determine whether or not your smoker has a problem with creosote, you can use a simple method that is nearly interesting enough to be included in a science experiment for fifth-graders.

What you need to do is hold a glass of ice water over the hole in your smoker where the smoke is coming out so that it can cool down the region.

Maintain the position of the glass of water in the smoke stream for one to five minutes, paying attention to the accumulation of any black specks on the surface of the glass.

If black specks do show up, Then you can congratulate yourself on the back for identifying the source of the problem.

As a result, your smoker is not receiving enough amount of ventilation, which results in accumulation within.

As adequate ventilation is a necessary condition for correctly smoking foods, once you’ve resolved this issue, the smoked flavor of your meals will improve accordingly.

Utilizing your senses is another method for determining whether or not creosote is present.

Creosote has the potential to make a person’s mouth and tongue feel tingly or numb, as was noted above.

After something has been cooked, take it out of the oven and let a bit of it sit on your tongue for a moment.

If, after one minute, you start to feel a tingling or numbing feeling on your tongue or cheeks, creosote is most likely the source of this reaction.

On the other hand, this method is not recommended because it requires you to waste an otherwise delicious piece of food in order to determine what kind of insanity is occurring inside your smoker.

However, if you have an item that you are prepared to give up, then you will not be unsuccessful in using this strategy.

Also Read: How Long To Smoke A Prime Rib? (Recommendations)

How To Clean Creosote From Smoker?

There are many different methods available for cleaning.

However, due to its sticky nature, creosote may be a real hassle to clean up after.

Now that we’ve established that, let’s speak about the choices in the order of simplest to most difficult.

Burning off creosote residue is the simplest method for removing creosote.

Before you get started with this, though, you should know that you should not do this if you are concerned about the paint on your smoker. It could potentially ruin your paint.

You are going to need a brush with a firm bristle and a torch that burns propane. You could use a wire brush, but there is a chance that it will scratch the surface.

  1. To begin, crack the lid of the smoker and leave it open for one minute so that it may air out.
  2. Put some light into your torch.
  3. Creosote should be burned (As you burn it, the creosote will bubble up and become brittle instead of sticky)
  4. If you want to eliminate all of the creosote, you must burn the lid, the walls, and the grates. 
  5. When all of the creosote has risen to the surface, scrape it off.
  6. Start a fresh fire in the smoker so that it can be reseasoned.

You can also use a wire brush, first remove any food or ash from the smoker.

Then, using a ladder if necessary, reach up into the smoker and begin scrubbing the walls with the wire brush

Work in small sections, and be sure to brush all of the creosote off of the walls.

To use a chemical cleaner, first, remove any food or ash from the smoker.

Then, using a ladder if necessary, reach up into the smoker and begin spraying the chemical cleaner onto the creosote-covered walls.

Be sure to follow the instructions on the cleaner carefully, as some cleaners require you to let them sit for a period of time before wiping them away.

Once you have removed all of the creosote from the smoker, it is important to prevent it from coming back.

One way to do this is to make sure that there is good ventilation in the smoker so that smoke can escape easily.

Another way to prevent creosote buildup is to regularly clean your chimney or stovepipe.

Other Potential Issues Causing Creosote  

Not Enough Oxygen 

If there isn’t enough oxygen present, the meat will turn black.

This is because oxygen is necessary for the chemical reaction that gives smoked meat its characteristic flavor. 

Too Much Smoke 

If there is too much smoke, it can cause the meat to turn black.

This is because the smoke can block the oxygen from getting to the meat, which prevents the chemical reaction from taking place. 

The Type Of Wood 

The type of wood you use can also affect the color of the meat.

For example, using a hardwood like oak will result in a darker color than using a softwood like cedar. 

The Temperature 

If the temperature is too high, it can cause the meat to turn black.

This is because high temperatures can cause the fat in the meat to render, which can make the meat appear darker. 

The Length Of Time 

The longer you smoke the meat, the darker it will become.

This is because the longer the meat is exposed to smoke, the more time there is for the smoke to penetrate into the flesh and change its color. 

The Moisture Content 

If the meat has a high moisture content, it will turn black more quickly than if it has a low moisture content.

This is because moisture helps to carry the smoke into the flesh of the meat, which speeds up the process of changing its color. 

The Fat Content 

Another reason why meat can turn black while smoking is due to fat.

If there’s too much fat on the meat, it can cause the temperature to drop, which will, in turn, cause the meat to turn black.


Finally, time is a factor that can cause the meat to turn black while smoking.

If the meat is smoked for too long, it will turn black.

Conversely, if it’s not smoked long enough, it will be pink in the middle and will not have that signature smoky flavor.

What Causes An Overproduction Of Smoke In A Smoker?

Overproduction Of Smoke In A Smoker

During the cooking process, if any oil or fat drips off the meal and into the burner, the oil will burn, producing a cloud of black smoke, and the food will be stained with black residue.

Inadequate ventilation can lead to excessive and stale smoke in the smoker as well as the production of an excessive amount of smoke.

Even though it is termed a “smoker,” if you create too little smoke during the cooking process, the meal won’t have the flavor you want, and if you create too much smoke, the flavor will be overwhelming.

So you gotta get it just perfect.

How To Prevent Your Smoker From Producing Too Much Smoke?

Inspect the valves, clean the smoker, evaluate the fuel, and monitor the temperature to avoid producing an excessive amount of smoke and allowing a coating of stale smoke to accumulate on the food you are smoking.

Follow these measures to ensure that your smoker is in good functioning condition and will not cause food to become charcoal-colored:

Step: 1

Check your smoker’s vent: It’s possible that anything as simple as a clogged vent is to blame for the accumulation of stale smoke inside the smoker.

First, you need to make sure that your smoker’s vent is producing the appropriate amount of smoke.

Perform this task once the smoker is heated and ready for use, but before adding any food to the chamber.

Then, even if the vent is obstructed, you won’t have to worry about throwing out any of the food.

Step: 2 

Clean your smoker often: The majority of manufacturers advise cleaning a smoker after every three to four hours of use.

Because it takes some time to clean a smoker, a lot of individuals make the unfortunate mistake of ignoring this step.

The vast majority of people would rather start cooking on the barbecue immediately rather than spend time cleaning it first.

The grill must be allowed to cool down after each use before it can be cleaned, but by the time it is ready to be cleaned, you will have moved on to other tasks by then.

However, a smoker who maintains their cleanliness will consistently deliver superior outcomes.

When the smoker gets hot, if there is any excess fat splatter or filth inside of it, it may start to emit black smoke from the burning oil. This is because black smoke contains carbon.

You obviously want to steer clear of situations like this one.

Step: 3 

Always check your fuel before a cook: Fuel of higher quality has a lower propensity to produce black smoke or an excessive amount of smoke.

If you do not have a deep understanding of wood and are unable to produce the appropriate quantity of woodchips for your smoker, it is in your best interest to purchase flavored wood pellets from reputable manufacturers.

If the pellets currently in the hopper produce an excessive amount of smoke, particularly black smoke, it may be time to switch brands.

Step: 4 

Ensure the fuel is at the right temperature: Allow your fuel and pellets sufficient time to attain their maximum heat potential.

If the smoke is dense and white, it may leave a film of soot on the meal or dominate the food with an unpleasant smoke taste.

A smoker is meant to smoke meat and other foods in a gentle manner.

Make it a habit to check that the fuel is burning completely and create the appropriate amount of smoke at all times.

If the smoke has a bluish hue and is not billowing in thick plumes, the product is ready to be used.

Is black soot on food from a grill safe to eat?

Black soot on your food is simply carbonized fat and oils from either the excess oil brushed onto the grilling surface or meat juices that drip down and coat it as part of the cooking process.

Eating foods with a bit of blackened soot is not rare and ordinarily won’t harm your health.

However, too much-charred tissue can pose health risks due to its unhealthy levels of carcinogens, which are cancer-causing compounds.

To allay these worries, it’s important to ensure the perfect grilling technique that involves keeping foods away from heaps of burning charcoal and preventing direct contact with high-heat flames.

Final Word

Because of a buildup of creosote in the smoker.

There are two basic reasons why a smoker may be turning food that should be wonderful into black waste that tastes terrible.

If there is not enough ventilation, the creosote will cover the food with a substance that could be harmful, and the smoke will not be able to escape.

The color of the meal will become more profound as a result of this.

Both of these difficulties can be readily rectified by properly cleaning the smoker as well as all of the vents.

Before you put food in the smoker, check that the fuel you are using is burning correctly and make sure it has been properly prepared.

Check the fuel you are using if the vents in the smoker are clear and the smoker itself is clean, but the food is still covered in black residue after smoking it.

Also Read: How Long To Smoke Baby Back Ribs? (An Easy Guide)

Leave a Comment